The Tripura High Court has imposed a Rs 10,000 cost on Oriental Insurance Company for delaying motor accident compensation to a deceased man’s family. The court dismissed the insurer’s revision petition, highlighting its unreasonable stand and prolonged deprivation of compensation.
The Tripura High Court has dismissed a civil revision petition filed by Oriental Insurance Company Ltd challenging an order for recovery of unpaid motor accident compensation, imposing a cost of Rs 10,000 on the insurance company for its prolonged delay in clearing the dues of a deceased man’s family.
A bench headed by Chief Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao delivered the judgment, observing that the insurance company had adopted an unreasonable stand that deprived the beneficiaries of their rightful compensation for several years. The court directed Oriental Insurance to pay the imposed cost of Rs 10,000 to the respondents within four weeks.
The case concerns compensation awarded to the family of Falguna Debbarma, who died in a motor accident. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No. 4, West Tripura, had initially awarded compensation of Rs 26,05,240, carrying interest at 7 per cent per annum from January 2, 2012, the date on which the claim petition was filed. The tribunal had also stipulated that the interest rate would to increase to 9 per cent if the compensation was not paid within two months.
The Oriental Insurance subsequently challenged the tribunal’s award before the High Court. On September 21, 2016, the High Court partly allowed the appeal and enhanced the compensation amount to Rs 28,72,670. It also directed the insurance company to pay interest at 9 per cent per annum from January 2, 2012, until the amount was fully paid.
The High Court had specifically instructed the insurer to deposit the enhanced portion of the compensation before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal. However, Oriental Insurance claimed that it had deposited the difference amount of Rs 4,48,577 before the Registrar General of the High Court in February 2018.
The deceased’s family later approached the tribunal seeking recovery of the outstanding compensation along with applicable interest. In response, the insurance company argued that the beneficiaries should approach the High Court to obtain the money allegedly deposited there.
On August 10, 2026, the tribunal observed that the insurer had failed to produce any material establishing that the compensation award had been fully satisfied. Consequently, it directed the issuance of notice to the District Collector for recovery of the outstanding amount along with interest.
Challenging this direction, the Oriental Insurance approached the High Court through a civil revision petition, repeating its argument that the amount had already been deposited before the High Court.
Rejecting the insurer’s contention, the High Court clarified that the original direction specifically required the enhanced compensation to be deposited before the tribunal. A deposit made before the High Court could not automatically be considered full satisfaction of the decretal debt, particularly when the insurance company failed to produce documentary proof of the alleged deposit.
| Also Read: Theft at Sarkartilla High School as Burglars Steal Electrical Wires |
The court further observed that the insurance company had the sufficient financial resources to clear the outstanding compensation. It could also have sought a refund of the amount allegedly deposited before the High Court by producing appropriate evidence.
Criticising the insurer’s conduct, the bench observed that its stand the lacked bona fides and had obstructed the family’s efforts to receive the compensation for years.
Accordingly, the High Court dismissed the civil revision petition and imposed costs of Rs 10,000 on Oriental Insurance Company, payable to the respondents within four weeks. All pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of.






